BJP’s Objection Over Distorting History Is The Double Standard Of 2017

BJP's Objection Over Distorting History Is The Double Standard Of 2017

In 2017, the Bhartiya Janata Birthday celebration (BJP) went from distorting historical past, because it has accomplished time and again up to now, to fabricating historical past to be able to advance its divisive ideology of Hindu nationalism.

Ignoring the pleas and protests in opposition to production historical past, the BJP government in Rajasthan changed fact to fiction within the Social Science textbook for Magnificence 10, this 12 months. The revised textbook says that Akbar misplaced the Fight of Haldighati to Maharana Pratap, even supposing historians have established that it used to be the Mughal emperor who defeated the Rajput king in 1576.

With the BJP shamelessly turning historical past on its head, its objections about ancient inaccuracies in Sanjay Leela Bhansali’s film Padmavati reek of hypocrisy. The ruling celebration comes throughout because the poster kid of double requirements.


The BJP’s opposition to the film concerning the Rajput queen, which began out with a couple of lawmakers writing letters, has amplified within the run as much as the Gujarat state election. The Hindu nationalist celebration now seems to be at the identical web page because the Shri Rajput Karni Sena, the perimeter staff that has been main a violent agitation in opposition to the multi-crore film.

Detractors, together with royal households from Rajasthan and Rajput ladies, are offended that the 13-14th century queen’s persona is noticed dancing within the movie. Additionally they consider that Bhansali’s movie has a romantic dream collection between the Rajput queen and the Muslim sultan Alauddin Khilji.

Even supposing Bhansali has stated that there’s no romantic dream collection within the movie, Karni Sena leaders have threatened to behead Bhansali and maim the film’s lead actor Deepika Padukone by way of chopping off her nostril.

BJP leaders have when put next distorting historical past to “treason.”

In a letter to the House Minister Rajnath Singh, a BJP chief from Uttar Pradesh, Arjun Gupta, wrote, “He (Bhansali) must be seriously punished by way of being attempted for treason for his try to distort historical past,” he stated. In a letter to Bhansali, Haryana minister Vipul Goel wrote, “No person is authorized to distort historical past and wrongly provide details.”

Gold same old of double requirements

Now, let us take a look at the BJP’s remedy of historical past and details.

In simply the previous 12 months, BJP governments in a minimum of two states have distorted historical past at school textbooks learn by way of hundreds of thousands of scholars, with extra states prone to observe.

The Rajasthan govt, as an example, has no longer simplest flipped the end result of the Haldighati fight, it has additionally portrayed VD Savarkar as a champion of the independence motion, sidelining Mahatma Gandhi and Jawaharlal Nehru. If truth be told, Savarkar had a restricted position within the freedom fight and he ended up begging the British to liberate him from jail.

It’s tragic and true that school rooms have at all times been a battlefield for political events to advertise their ideologies, whether or not the Congress, the BJP or the Left. Textbooks in Gujarat, a BJP bastion for over 20 years, had been riddled with falsehoods for a very long time. Within the contemporary previous, Muslims, Christians, Parsis and Jews have been offered as “foreigners” and Hitler, who murdered hundreds of thousands of Jews, used to be described as anyone who lent “dignity and prestige to the German govt.”

During the last 3 years, on the other hand, BJP’s presence on the Centre and in an extraordinary choice of states has strengthened the celebration’s plan to roll again what Hindu nationalists consider to be the domination of the Left and the “secular” thinkers in lecturers and “saffronise” historical past around the nation.

At the one hand, BJP is protesting over a rumored dream collection involving a Rajput queen, who might or would possibly not have even existed. Then again, the BJP is not only production historical past, but in addition erasing the historical past that demanding situations its linear narrative of the barbaric Muslim invaders who persecuted Hindus and destroyed their temples.

The Maharashtra govt, as an example, has removed from the historical past of the Mughal emperors and the Delhi Sultanate from the Magnificence eight textbook, and not using a point out of the monuments they constructed.

Scholars in Maharashtra will now not know about Muslims rulers like Razia Sultana, the primary girl to rule Delhi, Muhammad bin Tughlaq, who circulated cash of copper and brass as token forex, and Sher Shah Suri, who offered the primary “Rupia” and made the freeway that might in the end develop into the Grand Trunk Street.

The BJP govt in Uttar Pradesh could also be making plans to write down out Mughal emperors from state textbooks. In September, Deputy Leader Minister Dinesh Sharma stated the state’s syllabus would reflect that “Mughal rulers weren’t our ancestors however looters.”

“Do not inform me that phrases do not topic”

The BJP leaders do not even want a multi-crore movie to distort historical past. They do it mechanically in remarks and statements made to the click and at public purposes, with none compunction or responsibility.

Not like Bhansali, who has no selection however to answer the agitation in opposition to his movie, politicians are apparently answerable to nobody, neither the state nor the general public, let by myself fringe teams just like the Shri Rajput Karni Sena.

There’s not anything preventing Vinay Katiyar, a BJP lawmaker within the Rajya Sabha, from claiming that Mughal Emperor Shah Jahan destroyed a Shiva temple to construct the Taj Mahal, and calling for the arena well-known monument to be renamed Tejo Mahal.

Sooner than Katiyar, BJP lawmaker from UP, Sangeet Som, said that the Taj Mahal used to be made by way of a person who imprisoned his personal father. To the contrary, Shah Jahan, who constructed the Taj Mahal in reminiscence of his spouse, used to be imprisoned by way of his son Aurangzeb.

BJP leaders have no longer simplest misrepresented the rustic’s political, non secular and cultural historical past, they have got distorted medical historical past.

In 2015, as an example, Union Minister for Science and Era Harsh Vardhan said that Algebra and the Pythagoras Theorem originated in India. “Historic Indian scientists have graciously allowed scientists from different nations to take credit score for his or her findings,” he said.

Previous this 12 months, the junior schooling minister of India, Satya Good friend Singh, stated that an Indian student Shivkar Bapuji Talpade invented the plane, no longer the Wright Brothers. “This individual invented the aircraft 8 years prior to the Wright brothers,” he said.

Hindu nationalists have at all times portrayed historical India, prior to the approaching of Christianity and Islam, because the golden age of prosperity and finding out. They mechanically declare that breakthroughs in trendy medication, science and generation made within the final 100 years have been identified to other people residing in historical India.

In 2014, Narendra Modi become the primary high minister to publicly again the Vedic age idea of the Hindu proper.

Whilst talking at a serve as in Mumbai, Modi stated that historical Indians knew about genetic science and cosmetic surgery, bringing up examples of the warrior Karna from the epic Mahabharata and Ganesha, the Hindu god who has the top of an elephant.

“We worship Ganeshji, there will have to had been a plastic surgeon in that generation who put an elephant’s head on a human frame, cosmetic surgery will have to have began then,” he said.

Modi has spoken of Ganesha’s head and different imagined achievements of historical India when he used to be leader minister of Gujarat. Actually, within the run as much as the overall election in 2014, Modi habitually distorted historical past, claiming that Biharis defeated Alexander the Nice and that Takshashila used to be in Bihar (it’s in Pakistan).

Remaining week, Yogi Adityanath said, “Distorting historical past isn’t any lesser crime than sedition.”

Is the UP leader minister accusing his colleagues and his boss of sedition?

Additionally on HuffPost India:

Source link


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here